Buy Three, Ships Free!
Featured Product
- New -
Premium Reserve Toffee

Indulge in the Elegance of Artisan Toffee, A Gourmet Delight: Savor the extraordinary with our Premium Reserve Toffee, meticulously crafted for the discerning palate. Each box holds a generous 28 ounces of our most lavish toffee creation, a testament to our commitment to culinary excellence.

Exquisite Chocolate Enchantment: Our toffee is sumptuously coated in a rich, 46% cacao artisanal semi-sweet chocolate, ensuring a harmonious balance of flavors. This double draping of chocolate adds an irresistible depth to each bite.

Crafted Fresh for You: Embrace the freshness of our gourmet toffee, made exclusively to order. We guarantee that your toffee is prepared only after your order is placed, ensuring unparalleled freshness and quality. You will never receive toffee dated before your order.

The Pinnacle of Toffee Perfection: We proudly present a masterpiece, born from refining thousands of batches of our famous toffee recipe. Our relentless pursuit of perfection has led us to this moment, where each ingredient is thoughtfully chosen to create a toffee experience that is nothing short of divine.

Generosity in Every Box: Our Premium Reserve Toffee is not just a treat, it's an experience to be shared... or savored solo. Each box, containing nearly two pounds of toffee, is an ideal gift, a memorable party favor, or a luxurious treat for yourself. Suitable for serving 2 to 20 people, depending on how generous you're feeling.

Indulge in the Ultimate Toffee Experience: Discover the zenith of toffee craftsmanship with our Premium Reserve Toffee. It's more than a confection – it's a celebration of flavor, a journey of taste, and a tribute to the art of fine toffee making.

- $43 / 28oz (1.75lbs) -
View Details
Small Batch Handmade Almond Toffee
Classic Chocolate Almond Toffee
- $19 / pound -
Milk Chocolate Almond Toffee
- $19 / pound -
Spicy Chocolate Almond Toffee
- $19 / pound -
Salted Chocolate Almond Toffee
- $19 / pound -
Gourmet Candies
Pecan Brittle
- $22 / pound -
Old Fashioned Butterscotch - $16 / 8oz -
- New -
Bourbon Butterscotch - $21 / 8oz -
Habanero Butterscotch
- $16 / 8oz -
Featured Reviews
Verified Review The toffee was awesome as usual, but the bourbon butterscotch was amazing. I keep coming back for more! J. Furne Spicy Chocolate Almond Toffee
Bourbon Butterscotch
Verified Review This is delicious! The salted chocolate almond toffee is my favorite. I would highly recommend this as a gift to someone special. Claudia A. Classic Chocolate Almond Toffee
Verified Review I recently hosted a team meeting in Denver and was looking for a unique food product for my gift bags. In doing some research, I found that toffee was very popular. Colorado Toffee chef was willing to pair our bourbon with his toffee by creating a custom product. The finished product was delicious!! Chef Michael was a pleasure to work with. Robin C. Spicy Chocolate Almond Toffee
Bourbon Butterscotch
Verified Review The pecan brittle was outstanding!! I bought two boxes - one to take to a dinner party, and one for me. Good thing because the box for the party was half eaten before we got there! SO GOOD!!! Holly Pecan Brittle
Verified Review Very much enjoyed my first order! ! Anxious to try all the flavors! Spreading the Colorado Toffee name throughout Minnesota. A friend of mine has ordered 3 times!! Sharon D. From Minnesota Classic Chocolate Almond Toffee
Verified Review I received a box of the milk chocolate almond toffee as part of my gift for Mother's Day. So glad my daughter introduced me to these! I could have eaten the whole box in one sitting. Not only did the toffee taste wonderful but it was in a cute box. I am definitely going to be ordering these to give as gifts. And of course, I look forward to ordering more of the milk chocolate and trying out the others as well! Bea N. Milk Chocolate Almond Toffee
Verified Review Just got my first (of many) order of toffee. We got the Salted Chocolate Almond and Milk Chocolate Almond. Both were DELICIOUS! They came in a timely manner, in an adorable box, which makes me think this is a great gift idea and amazing! I give this an A++ and will be ordering again soon! Tegan C. Milk Chocolate Almond Toffee


Q: Is my payment secure?
A: Yes! I use a payment proscessor named Stripe which powers payments for over a million companies on the internet. I never see your payment details.
Q: Can I change my order and add things?
A: Yes! As long as your order has not shipped yet you can contact me at to change your order.
Q: What makes your toffee so much better than other toffee's I have tried?
A: I use the freshest ingredients I can get my hands on, I never add any artificial preservatives or bad tasting emulsifiers, I use family techniques that have been passed down through the generations, and I make every order fresh. I strongly believe that this makes the best Toffee money can buy.

Have a Question not listed? Ask me
Colorado Toffee is a family owned small business. Our family's toffee recipe has been around for so long that there's no written copy of it. Every batch of toffee is hand made to order with care. Our English style almond toffee is made with only water, sugar, almonds, butter, chocolate, and a pinch of salt. Order plenty, we promise you'll love it.